Guide
How to read a government RFP: mandatory requirements, rated criteria and price
A request for proposals from a Canadian public buyer can run past a hundred pages, but only four parts decide who wins: the mandatory requirements, the rated criteria, the pricing rules and the basis of selection. Find those first. You can usually tell within an hour whether the bid is worth writing.
1. Start with the dates and the rules of submission
Note the closing date and time (and its time zone), the deadline for questions, any site visit or bidders’ meeting and whether it is mandatory, and how the bid must be delivered. A missed mandatory site visit ends your bid before you write a word.
2. Mandatory requirements: pass or fail
Mandatory requirements are the conditions marked with “must” or “shall”: a licence, a minimum number of years of experience, a number of similar projects, a security clearance, insurance, a signed form. Each one is pass or fail. A proposal that misses a single mandatory requirement is set aside and the rest is not scored. List them all and check each against what you can prove, not what you can do.
3. Rated criteria: where the points are
Rated criteria are scored. The RFP publishes each criterion, the points it carries and often what a full-mark answer contains. Many RFPs also set a minimum pass mark, overall or per criterion; a proposal below it is out, whatever its price. Put your effort where the points are, and answer each criterion under its own heading in the order the RFP uses. Evaluators score what they can find.
4. Price: follow the form exactly
The RFP says how to state the price: a fixed total, unit prices, hourly rates by category of staff, with or without tax. Use the buyer’s pricing form unchanged. A price that adds conditions, leaves a line blank or reorganizes the table can make the whole proposal non-compliant.
5. The basis of selection
One paragraph states how the winner is chosen. The common methods are:
- Lowest price among compliant proposals: meet every mandatory requirement and the pass mark, then the cheapest wins.
- Highest combined score: technical merit and price are weighted, for example 70 per cent technical and 30 per cent price, and the best total wins.
- Best technical score within a budget: the buyer states the budget and the strongest proposal at or under it wins.
The method tells you how to bid. Under lowest price, anything beyond the pass mark is wasted cost. Under a combined score, a stronger proposal can beat a cheaper one.
6. The contract you would be signing
The draft contract is attached to the RFP: term and extension options, payment terms, insurance, ownership of what you produce, penalties. In most public competitions you accept these terms by bidding and cannot negotiate them afterwards. Read them before you price.
7. Decide: bid or pass
Pass if you miss a mandatory requirement, if the rated criteria reward experience you do not have, or if you cannot do the work at a price that wins. Otherwise ask your questions early in the question period and start writing. To see what is open now, go to open RFPs in Canada; for the other notice types, read the notice types explained.
Questions
What happens if my proposal misses one mandatory requirement?
It is declared non-compliant and set aside. The rated criteria and the price are not evaluated, however strong they are.
Does the lowest price always win a government RFP?
No. It depends on the basis of selection stated in the RFP. Many RFPs weight technical merit and price together, so a higher-scoring proposal can win at a higher price. Requests for quotation and tenders usually do go to the lowest compliant price.
Can I negotiate the contract terms after I win?
Usually not. In most Canadian public competitions the draft contract is part of the RFP and submitting a bid accepts it. Raise any concern during the question period, before closing.