Guide
Lost a government bid? Debriefs, bid protests and what to do next
Most bids lose; a competition with six bidders has five losers. What separates the vendors who eventually win is what they do in the two weeks after a loss. Ask for a debrief every time. Consider a formal complaint only when the buyer broke its own rules.
1. Ask for a debrief
A debrief is the buyer’s explanation of how your bid was evaluated. Ask in writing as soon as you receive the regret letter or see the award notice; many solicitations set a deadline, often within 15 working days. Federal buyers provide debriefs on request, and most provincial and municipal buyers do as well.
You can normally learn:
- your score on each rated criterion and the reasons for it;
- which mandatory requirement you failed, if any;
- the name of the winner and the value of the contract awarded;
- how your total compared with the winning total.
You will not be shown the other bidders’ proposals or their unit prices. Go to listen, not to argue: the evaluator’s comments are the most accurate guide you will get to what this buyer rewards.
2. Check what was published
Award notices are public for contracts covered by the trade agreements, and many municipalities publish bid results and the staff report recommending the award. The winning price tells you whether you were close. Over a few competitions, the pattern tells you what the work is worth to that buyer.
3. When a formal complaint makes sense
A complaint is for a breach of the rules, not for a result you disagree with. Grounds that succeed are specific: the buyer applied criteria that were not in the documents, accepted a late or non-compliant bid, ignored its own stated method, or wrote requirements that only one supplier could meet.
- Start with the buyer. Write to the contracting authority named in the solicitation, stating the rule and the facts. Many issues end there.
- Federal contracts covered by a trade agreement: the Canadian International Trade Tribunal (CITT) hears complaints. The time limit is short: a complaint must generally be filed within 10 working days of the day you learned, or should have learned, of the grounds.
- Lower-value federal contracts: the Office of the Procurement Ombud reviews complaints about awards below the trade agreement values and about how a contract is being administered.
- Provincial and municipal contracts: each body has its own bid dispute or protest procedure, described in its procurement policy or in the solicitation. The courts are the last resort.
Because the time limits are short, raise a problem in the documents during the question period, before closing. An objection to the wording of the requirements made after you lose is usually too late.
4. Use it on the next bid
- Keep the debrief notes with the proposal, and fix the weakest scored section first.
- Bid again with the same buyer. Evaluators score a familiar, compliant bidder with more confidence.
- Watch for the renewal. Most contracts come back to market when their term ends.
For the full path from registration to submission, read how to win your first government contract.
Questions
Can I find out why I lost a government bid?
Yes. Ask the contracting authority in writing for a debrief. You can normally learn your scores, the reasons for them, the winner's name and the contract value, though not the contents of other bids.
How long do I have to challenge a federal contract award?
For contracts covered by a trade agreement, a complaint to the Canadian International Trade Tribunal must generally be filed within 10 working days of learning the grounds for it.
Is it worth filing a bid protest?
Only when you can point to a specific rule the buyer broke, such as using unpublished criteria or accepting a non-compliant bid. Disagreeing with the scores is not enough.